-
Conveyancing
ConveyancingMore Information
-
Debt & Insolvency
Debt & InsolvencyMore Information
-
Employment
EmploymentMore Information
-
Family Law
Family LawMore Information
-
Divorce & Dissolution
Divorce & DissolutionMore Information
-
Childcare & Children
Childcare & ChildrenMore Information
-
Divorce & Dissolution
-
Medical Negligence
Medical NegligenceMore Information
-
Birth Injury & Pregnancy Claims
Birth Injury & Pregnancy ClaimsMore Information
-
Cardiac & Heart Negligence
Cardiac & Heart NegligenceMore Information
-
Cauda Equina Syndrome
Cauda Equina SyndromeMore Information
-
Cerebral Palsy
Cerebral PalsyMore Information
-
Cosmetic Dentistry Claims
Cosmetic Dentistry ClaimsMore Information
-
Cosmetic Surgery Claims
Cosmetic Surgery ClaimsMore Information
-
Essure Implant Claims
Essure Implant ClaimsMore Information
-
Gender Affirmation Claims
Gender Affirmation ClaimsMore Information
-
GP & Misdiagnosis Claims
GP & Misdiagnosis ClaimsMore Information
-
Hernia Mesh Claims
Hernia Mesh ClaimsMore Information
-
Hospital Acquired Infections
Hospital Acquired InfectionsMore Information
-
Inquest Representation
Inquest RepresentationMore Information
-
Late/Misdiagnosed Cancer Claim
Late/Misdiagnosed Cancer ClaimMore Information
-
Organ Transplant Surgery
Organ Transplant SurgeryMore Information
-
Pressure Sores
Pressure SoresMore Information
-
Prolapse Surgery
Prolapse SurgeryMore Information
-
Surgical Errors
Surgical ErrorsMore Information
-
Sepsis Claims
Sepsis ClaimsMore Information
-
Vaginal Mesh Implant Claims
Vaginal Mesh Implant ClaimsMore Information
-
Birth Injury & Pregnancy Claims
-
Personal Accident & Injury
Personal Accident & InjuryMore Information
-
Accidents in the Workplace
Accidents in the WorkplaceMore Information
-
Accidents in Public Places
Accidents in Public PlacesMore Information
-
Asbestos & Mesothelioma
Asbestos & MesotheliomaMore Information
-
Criminal Injuries
Criminal InjuriesMore Information
-
Diving Claims & Accidents at Sea
Diving Claims & Accidents at SeaMore Information
-
Head & Brain Injury Claims
Head & Brain Injury ClaimsMore Information
-
Occupational Disease
Occupational DiseaseMore Information
-
Road Traffic Accidents
Road Traffic AccidentsMore Information
-
Vibration White Finger
Vibration White FingerMore Information
-
Compensation Calculator
Compensation CalculatorMore Information
-
Accidents in the Workplace
-
Personal Disputes
Personal DisputesMore Information
Bridge McFarland LLP has a team of highly-regarded lawyers based in Hull, Grimsby and Lincoln with formidable experience and expertise in all forms of dispute resolution including High Court and County Court litigation and all forms of Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR), including mediation, expert determination, adjudication and arbitration.
-
Internet and Social Media Law
Internet and Social Media LawMore Information
The ever-growing popularity of social media websites and apps such as Facebook, YouTube, Twitter, LinkedIn, Pinterest, Google Plus+, Instagram, Tumblr and Reddit have led to a sharp rise in online defamation, cyber-bullying, harassment and privacy, confidentiality and data protection issues. These are problems which affect individuals and businesses alike.
-
Judicial Review
Judicial ReviewMore Information
Judicial Review is the process by which the courts supervise public bodies to ensure that they act lawfully and fairly. Judicial reviews can be used to challenge the decisions and actions of a range of public bodies, including local authorities, government departments, NHS trusts and clinical commissioning groups, schools and governing bodies, magistrates, county courts, coroners, chief constables and public governors.
-
Personal Dispute Funding
Personal Dispute FundingMore Information
The legal process can be lengthy, with some cases taking months, or even years, to resolve. This can put a heavy financial strain on both businesses and individuals in terms of paying your own costs. The good news is that Bridge McFarland LLP can provide an integrated package of funding solutions for your costs and disbursements.
-
Property & Housing Disputes
Property & Housing DisputesMore Information
-
Professional Negligence
Professional NegligenceMore Information
If you have been let down by a professional advisor, such as a solicitor, accountant or surveyor, our professional negligence lawyers can help you to claim compensation.
-
Trust & Probate Disputes
Trust & Probate DisputesMore Information
-
Internet and Social Media Law
-
Professional Negligence
Professional NegligenceMore Information
If you have been let down by a professional advisor, such as a solicitor, accountant or surveyor, our professional negligence lawyers can help you to claim compensation.
-
Financial Services Negligence
Financial Services NegligenceMore Information
Financial Services Negligence
-
Lawyer Negligence
Lawyer NegligenceMore Information
-
Property Negligence
Property NegligenceMore Information
Property Negligence
-
SIPP and Pension Claims
SIPP and Pension ClaimsMore Information
-
Under-settled Claims
Under-settled ClaimsMore Information
-
Financial Services Negligence
-
Sports Law
Sports LawMore Information
-
Wills, Trusts & Probate
Wills, Trusts & ProbateMore Information
-
Enduring or Lasting Powers of Attorney
Enduring or Lasting Powers of AttorneyMore Information
-
Trusts
TrustsMore Information
-
Probate
ProbateMore Information
-
Statutory Wills
Statutory WillsMore Information
-
Contesting a Will
Contesting a WillMore Information
-
Enduring or Lasting Powers of Attorney
Legal Services
-
Agriculture & Rural Business
Agriculture & Rural BusinessMore Information
-
Agricultural Landholding
Agricultural LandholdingMore Information
-
Conservation & Environment
Conservation & EnvironmentMore Information
-
Criminal Justice & Public Order
Criminal Justice & Public OrderMore Information
-
Land Use
Land UseMore Information
-
Taxation & Rights
Taxation & RightsMore Information
-
Town & Country Planning
Town & Country PlanningMore Information
-
Agricultural Landholding
-
Business Contracts
Business ContractsMore Information
-
Business Terms & Conditions
Business Terms & ConditionsMore Information
-
Business Terms & Conditions
-
Commercial Property
Commercial PropertyMore Information
-
Company Formations
Company FormationsMore Information
-
Debt Recovery
Debt RecoveryMore Information
-
Funding For Debt Recovery
Funding For Debt RecoveryMore Information
-
Pre-Action for Debt Recovery
Pre-Action for Debt RecoveryMore Information
-
Legal Proceedings for Debt Recovery
Legal Proceedings for Debt RecoveryMore Information
-
Enforcement for Debt Recovery
Enforcement for Debt RecoveryMore Information
-
Funding For Debt Recovery
-
Dispute Resolution
Dispute ResolutionMore Information
-
Construction & Engineering
Construction & EngineeringMore Information
-
Contract Disputes
Contract DisputesMore Information
-
Injunctions
InjunctionsMore Information
-
Intellectual Property Disputes
Intellectual Property DisputesMore Information
-
Internet & IT Disputes
Internet & IT DisputesMore Information
-
Company & Partnership Disputes
Company & Partnership DisputesMore Information
-
Property Disputes
Property DisputesMore Information
-
Alternative Dispute Resolution
Alternative Dispute ResolutionMore Information
-
Funding Commercial Disputes
Funding Commercial DisputesMore Information
-
Professional Negligence for Business
Professional Negligence for BusinessMore Information
-
Construction & Engineering
-
Employment Law
Employment LawMore Information
-
Insolvency
InsolvencyMore Information
-
Licensing
LicensingMore Information
-
Mergers, Sales & Acquisitions
Mergers, Sales & AcquisitionsMore Information
-
Property Development
Property DevelopmentMore Information
-
Sports Law
Sports LawMore Information
Legal Services
















Can a summary dismissal be fair without a single act of gross misconduct?

Yes, said the EAT in Mbubaegbu v Homerton University NHS Foundation Trust.
Added 19th June, 2018
BUT, this case comes with a health warning…the facts are unusual and although it is a preferential case for employers, care should be taken before reliance is placed on it.
In this case, Mr Mbubaegbu, a consultant orthopaedic surgeon with an unblemished record was dismissed summarily over 17 incidents of misconduct. Not one act in itself constituted gross misconduct. However, the NHS Trust felt that taken as a series of incidents, he failed to demonstrate in the disciplinary hearing that he had learnt from his mistakes or was willing to change. This led to a finding of gross misconduct based upon a breakdown in the mutual obligation of trust and confidence.
Mr Mbubaegbu worked in the Homerton NHS Trust for over 15 years. During 2013, new rules and responsibilities following concerns over patient safety were implemented and staff were informed that they would be monitored. Following an initial investigation, there had been non-compliance by 5 consultants including Mr Mbubaegbu. A subsequent investigation followed into Mr Mbubaegbu and one other.
The disciplinary process took 16 months to complete. In that time there were no further reported incidences of non-compliance and Mr Mbubaegbu continued to practice. However, at the end of the disciplinary process, he was summarily dismissed. He was unsuccessful on appeal.
Mr Mbubaegbu brought claims for, amongst other things, unfair dismissal in the ET. The ET held by a majority that his dismissal was fair so Mr Mbubaegbu appealed to the EAT.
The EAT upheld the original judgment. It concluded that the pattern of behaviour which gave rise to the concerns regarding patient safety was a sufficient reason to dismiss and found that it was within the band of reasonable responses. The EAT went on to confirm that there is nothing to say that there must be a single act of gross misconduct to justify a summary dismissal. Conduct, which, if it is determined to be “sufficiently serious” to undermine the relationship of trust and confidence can also be sufficient to justify summary dismissal.
This case is unusual and does turn on the facts so before you rely on it to dismiss an employee summarily for acts of misconduct, please speak to Joanne Wright or your usual Employment specialist.